Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Confusing Ken Wilber's Integral Movement with Integral Yoga of Sri Aurobindo

M. Alan Kazlev is a self-taught esotericist and metaphysician, science fiction writer and fan, amateur biologist and palaeontologist, and student of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother's teachings and yoga. His website is at www.kheper.net and he can be contacted at alankazlev (at) ihug (dot) com (dot) au (sorry – problems with spam!). For Integral World he has written two series of essays on integral philosophy: Towards a Larger View of Integral (4 Parts) and Integral Esotericism (8 Parts). In the following essay he gives on overview of the integral landscape.

Redefining Integral M. Alan Kazlev

Authors note: this essay builds upon and incorporates an earlier blog post on Integral Praxis integralpraxis.blogspot.com/ . In the process of writing it, I revised and refined my original position considerably, so that in places it is almost unrecognisable. I would like to thank everyone who commented on these posts and added their own feedback and critiques; I have tried to incorporate this into the current thesis. To help with the flow of text, I have avoided the use of footnotes in this essay. There is also a pragmatic reason for this: in order to cite everything the essay would need many pages of footnotes! Instead, important books have been referenced in the text itself. I have also included various on-line urls, but again, not a comprehensive selection. This essay updates and complements my earlier essays on Integral World

1. Synopsis
In this essay, I re-define "Integral" in a way that includes all current definitions. This involves five definitions: Religious, Theoretical, Practical, Enlightened, and Divinised. Each of these definitions is defined. Of these, the first is considered pseudo-integral, the others authentically integral. This gives us a broader framework that can accommodate, but also go beyond, the various more limited definitions. A lot of difficulty also arises from confusing the Integral Movement as defined by Ken Wilber and Don Beck with Integral Yoga as defined by Sri Aurobindo. I show that these are very different; they are radically different teachings based on totally different states of consciousness..

A sequence of stages of the evolution of consciousness and society is also presented, which includes stages beyond the current Post-Materialism and Integral stages consciousness, is suggested, and the first of these, called Post-Integral, is briefly described.

What's new? Reading Room Wilber Watch My Wilber Book Links Contact
Reading Room Essays Top 50

DIEM-LANE Recommended Readings on Quantum Theory
WILBER
Ken Wilber on His Health
MARTIN-SMITH
The Future of Art and Art Criticism
WILBER
Ken Wilber Videos on YouTube
MEYERHOFF
Bald Ambition: Table of Contents
HARRIS
Aryan Patriarchy, Dravidian Matriarchy
DIEM-LANE
The Einstein-Bohr Crapshoot
EDWARDS
The Depth of the Exteriors, Part II
VISSER
Ken Wilber: Thought as Passion
HARRIS
Christianity: The Great Lie
EDWARDS
The Integral Cycle of Knowledge
MARTIN-SMITH
Art and Postmodern Criticism
VISSER
The Wild West Wilber Report
HELFRICH
Ken Wilber's AQAL Metatheory
McINTOSH
Beauty, Truth and Goodness
ROSADO
What is Spirituality?
KAZLEV
Integral Theory
DIEM-LANE
Quantum Weirdness
MARTIN
The Human Growth Continuum
EDWARDS
A Brief History of Holons
EDWARDS
The Depth of the Exteriors, Part I
WILPERT
Dimensions of Integral Politics
VISSER
The Wilberian Evolution Report
MEYERHOFF
Psychological Analysis of Wilber's Beliefs
DIEM-LANE
Einstein Doesn't Play Dice
MEYERHOFF
Poststructuralism and Postmodernism
ANONYMOUS
Meditation Notes from Ken Wilber
BECK
Stages of Social Development
BROUWER
The Wilber-Combs Lattice Revisited
VISSER
Integral Design: Wilber on Evolution
MEYERHOFF
Six Criticisms of Wilber's Integral Theory
ISHAQ
The Science of Sufism
BENJAMIN
Integral Mathematics
VISSER
New Light on the Near-Death Experience?
DIEM-LANE
Bohr Plays Poker
SHEPHERD
Critical Comments on Perennialist Philosophy
VISSER
Ken Wilber's Mysterianism
SORENSEN
Two Versions of Psychosynthesis
VISSER
A Spectrum of Wilber Critics
WILBER
Some Thoughts on Integral Politics
VISSER
Perennialism, Postmodernism, Integralism
BENJAMIN
Wilber vs. Schneider
VISSER
My Critical Essays on Ken Wilber
BENEDIKTER
Postmodern Spirituality, Part I
VISSER
If You Meet Ken Wilber On The Road...
BENJAMIN
On Ken Wilber's Integral Institute
DAWKINS
Dawkins on Darwin (OU Lecture)
KAZLEV
Redefining Integral
LARSSON
Spiritual Narcissism
SALMON
Integral Psychology Beyond Wilber-V