Sunday, October 03, 2021

Bergson, Saussure, and Althusser

Assorted tweets collated by @NathTusar, Founder of SELF (2005), Savitri Era Religion (2006), and Savitri Era Party (2007)

Any good points? Then only one can measure someone's worth objectively. One example: he was responsible for marginalising Subhas in an unjust manner. And later, Sri Aurobindo too disliked the latter's joining hands with Hitler. So, Gandhi was an instrument of Evolutionary forces.
Many wrong impressions circulate apropos Sri Aurobindo due to quotations taken out of context. Much misunderstanding has indurated regarding his views on Gandhi, Muslims, AIT, Partition, etc. Savitri Era Party takes independent stand on present problems by keeping aside his words
To reiterate What I tweeted in 2018, Gandhi proved to be an effective antidote against Hindutva as well as aligning with Hitler. To that extent he served Sri Aurobindo's purpose.
Savitri Era
@SavitriEra
·
Sri Aurobindo declined to meet him but that doesn't exactly mean that Sri Aurobindo was against Gandhi. Churchill was wrong in many respects but Sri Aurobindo found him to be the most fit instrument to confront Hitler. Thus, history is a bit more comlex when #SriAurobindo enters.
Music to my ears but just think of yourself wasting precious years on Gandhi because of your father's influence. It's great that you find virtue in Sri Aurobindo now, but you have published precious little on him. The whole environment was like that. It will take some years now.
Critical appraisal is not opposition; it's done out of sympathy. But Gandhi was in the field and had to be utilised for specific purposes. Hindutva, as we understand today, was absent then. By Hindus, Sri Aurobindo meant Indians. There was no communal angle in his thinking.
Replying to and
Each person has his good and bad side. Gandhi needn't be mocked in such derogatory way. A more scientific and objective appraisal is warranted.
Replying to
There must be a reason why Gandhi and Sri Aurobindo were born in opposite sides of India and never met during three decades. Present generation must probe into this whole scenario for a wealth of information and insights is waiting to be discovered. This is an Evolutionary task.
Evergreen Essays: Gandhi was a master of the political deployment of ritual evergreenessays.blogspot.com/2019/07/gandhi , Director, Savitri Era Learning Forum (SELF), Indirapuram, Ghaziabad - 201014 (UP) #FiveDreams #WorldUnion Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.
While Sri Aurobindo disagreed with Gandhiji at some points there was no one who appreciated diversity of expression and of being more than Sri Aurobindo twitter.com/brahmavidvariy
Please do read me I interrogate and debate his ideas across papers and books as philosophers are want to do but I continue to learn lessons of humanity and respect for difference from him
There was great appreciation for diversity of self expression in Ari Aurobindo and in Gandhi ! Sri Aurobindo wrote on the difference between unity and uniformity! It will be unjustified to think that he characterised Gandhi as “bad” ! I have upcoming books on both thinkers !
He called him " ethical", not " bad."
They see the whole, the good points and minus points in the whole. Gandhi has many positive virtues like his theory of basic education and non-coperation which he took from Sri Aurobindo without acknowledgement. Usually they don't use the word "bad."
Sri Aurobindo only comments on his attitude to life, not on the pitfalls in his life. But even Gandhi's attitude to life and politics didn't match with Sri Aurobindo's, especially in the early 1940s, when Sri Aurobindo declined to meet him. Pl read SA n the Cripps Mission.

Mohomaya bhi satya hai, SriHari bhi satya hai. Mohomaya aur Jiban ko bhagana nahi, unki roopantar Sri Aurobindo ka YOG hai .

I think it might have been in the sense that Gandhi's spiritual endeavors were really restricted to the domain of morality or ethics & did not rise beyond. When I tried to follow Gandhi that's all I cud derive. Gandhism at best rose to level of moral purity & principled idealism.
What is Maya for the ignorant, unaware of Hari, is Mata for the seeker of Hari & Shakti for the knower who has found identity with Hari. Sri Aurobindo shows us the secret of Maya, one with Hari & Genetrix working out Truth-Creation in matters mould, the reason even we came about.
A basic requirement to know the Truth is to set aside preconceived notions. Read this article revealing why allying with Hitler was a big blunder by Bose. I am not a Bengali but my Guru Sri Aurobindo was Bengali by birth yet universal in outlook
Dr. Bhaskar Yogi spoke about conspiracy by British to divide the nation starting 4m divisive activity among Sikhs by Max Arthur Macauliffe to Bengal partition in 1905. #SriAurobindo inspired the nation to undo partition not just for geography but bcos Bharat is Divine
Informing the life and message of Sri Aurobindo for all is the task at hand To understand the vision of Akhand Bharat and its interpretation, every citizen must know the life and message of Sri Aurobindo, that is Hindu-centric thought and philosophy.
Savitri Era Religious Fraternity: Need to look at Sri Aurobindo as the torchbearer of Evolution serfrat.blogspot.com/2021/10/need-t Assorted tweets collated by , Founder of SELF (2005), Savitri Era Religion (2006), and Savitri Era Party (2007). Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.
Savitri Era: What Sri Aurobindo was doing during his last years savitriera.blogspot.com/2021/10/what-s Tweets in original by Tusar Nath Mohapatra Founder of SELF (2005) Savitri Era Religion (2006) Savitri Era Party (2007) Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.
It is fascinating that prominent figures of the Indian national movement (across the political spectrum) like Radhakrishnan, Aurobindo, Iqbal engaged with the ideas of Bergson in some way. Can't find any work that shows this aspect.
I just published Sri Aurobindo and Saussure link.medium.com/Log3piKl2jb

What about our inner defects?… - A more difficult topic today, for my new YouTube video. So it is a longer one too, as many not so helpful beliefs abound, particularly in most religions, ...

The Divine Manifestation and the Role of Individual - First and foremost the individual must be more and more an example among others. This is the best way to spread and radiate the New Consciousness. The po...

Further thoughts on Sanskrit philosophical commentaries - The main thing about Sanskrit philosophical commentaries is that they are the standard way of doing philosophy. For centuries, they were almost the only wa...

Rajesh Sampat on Ambedkar - Hegel and C.S Pierce believed in an objective logic- a 'logic of things'- whereas Althusser and other Marxists seeking to explain why the European prole...

Sri Aurobindo’s View of the Supramental Transformation - The spiritual landscape is vast, and there are innumerable objectives and paths that can be taken. Sri Aurobindo describes briefly his approach to spiritua...

Thou shalt not lie - Immanuel Kant famously taught that we should treat all human beings as ends in themselves, and never simply as means. The categorical imperative imposes a ...

Aarohan- ep.31 “Nirgun Nirakar Tradition of Bhakti Music” - Pt. Vijay Sardeshmukh Vidushi Veena Sahasrabuddhe Pt. Mukul Shivutra GaanSaraswati Kishori Amonkar

Kathāmṛta - 58 - Alaṅkāravatī-lambaka - The Story of Anaṅgaratī - The story of Anaṅgaratī The city of Śūrapura was ruled by king Mahāvarāha. His queen was Padmaratī and their only daughter was Anaṅgaratī. When the prince...

Imperial death and belonging in Alexandria, Egypt - Over and again, the stories of Jessie Brown and other foreign nationals of Alexandria demonstrated that death defined the living. It was this bureaucracy a...

The most important thing in your life — Mother - 22 June 1955 Mother reads from Lights on Yoga, “Planes and Parts of the Being”. Q: How can one awaken his Yogashakti? Mother: It depends on this: when one ...

Friday, September 10, 2021

Polar difference between Vivekananda’s idea and Kendra’s

Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra

International Journal of Humanities, Art and Social Studies (IJHAS), Vol. 3, No.2, May 2018 93 PHILOSOPHY OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA AND SRI AUROBINDO A CRITICAL ANALYSIS S. Lalitha Asst Prof. of English, Meenakshi College of Engineering, Chennai ABSTRACT 
Sri Aurobindo, was an Indian nationalist, freedom fighter, philosopher, yogi, guru and poet. He joined the Indian movement for freedom from British rule, for a while became one of its influential leaders and then turned into a spiritual reformer, introducing his visions on human progress and spiritual evolution. 
Swami Vivekananda, known in his pre-monastic life as Narendranath Datta, was born in an affluent family in Kolkata. His father,Vishwanath Datta, was a successful attorney with interests in a wide range of subjects, and his mother, Bhuvaneshwari Devi, was endowed with deep devotion, strong character and other qualities. A precocious boy, Narendra excelled in music, gymnastics and studies. By the time he graduated from Calcutta University, he had acquired a vast knowledge of different subjects, especially Western philosophy and history. These, then the Shâstras, the Guru, and the Mother¬land are the three notes that mingle themselves to form the music of the works of Vivekananda .The present paper brings out the critical analysis of the philosophies of the two great spiritual philosophers and writers in a comparative style. 

[PDF] Vivekananda and Vivekananda Kendra; A Critical Appraisal

CS Hota, S Panda - International Journal of Recent Advances …, 2021 - journals.resaim.com
7 days ago - Swami Vivekananda, a prominent figure of 19th century India has not only
being represented or misrepresented through his ideas and persona but he is being used as
an institutional assert. There are numerous institutions, both private and public, has been …
Often the question arises what is the need to have Vivekananda Kendra to fulfill the unfulfilled vision of Vivekananda as we know Ramakrishna math and mission was enough to carry the vision of Sri Ramakrishna Vivekananda ideal. Unlike Vivekananda Kendra, Ramakrishna math gives and overall evaluation of Vivekananda starting from philosophy, literature, nation, religion and Indian situation. This input open up the boundary of discussion. Of course it is often accused or not beings critical to Vivekananda philosophy. This hagiographic account really helps us to provide a base for further discussions. Surprisingly Ramakrishna mission also takes up seva, service and sangathan. In 1889 Vivekananda himself serve the plague victims and that trend still goes on. So for a common man it reminds us as a pertinent questions that, why Kendra in spite of the presence of Ramakrishna math? Somewhere other when we proceed further we see polar difference between Vivekananda’s idea and Kendra’s idea. Whereas Vivekananda talked about a composite plural Indian society, Kendra lays its stress upon the idea of Hindu nation. Vivekananda did not believe seva, puja or sanghatan to confront with some other institutions or some other faith. The church of Kanyakumari and Kendra’s confrontation is already pointed out. Of course, Vivekananda did not want that glorious Bharat born out or confrontation with other faith of religion. He was a man for tolerance, openness, nonsectarian and a true Hindu.

Rainbow & the Other: Bipin Chandra Pal articulated with greater eloquence the idea of Swaraj rainbowther.blogspot.com/2021/09/bipin- Part II of the edition on “Gandhi and Swaraj” opens with Ramachandra Pradhan’s succinct explanation of how Gandhi’s theory of swaraj was fundamental lanation of how Gandhi’s theory of swaraj was fundamental to his thinking that carried part of a religious tradition that traces back to classical Indian scriptures. Then the idea is revived by the moderates and extremists. Pradhan correctly mentions the key figures in this development, giving Aurobindo his due by expressing the spiritual, not merely political, dimensions of the concept. B C Pal is mentioned but not given credit for his brilliant, extraordinary Madras speeches that clearly state as early as 1907: “The movement for Swaraj is not a mere economic movement [but] essentially a spiritual movement….” Pal thus articulated with greater eloquence the idea of swaraj than any of the other nationalist leaders (Pal 1907: 26–28, 72–73, 85–86). Therefore, it is not the case, as Pradhan claims, that “of all the Extremist leaders, Aurobindo alone could visualise swaraj in the form of absolute political independence” (p 72). Yet, Pradhan is correct that Gandhi conceived this core concept within a rich intellectual context of thought that was rightly termed by Aurobindo the “Indian renaissance.” Ghosh (1951: 39–40) and most recently, Nalini Bhushanand Jay Garfi eld (2017). The latter regrettably fails to mention B C Pal.

surprising that some ‘I know more than everyone‘ type devotees of d Mother claim that we shouldn’t believe in our Gods once we’re on d path of #SriAurobindo ! It was a different matter that Lord Ganesh too couldn’t fulfill all d demands of TM !!
https://twitter.com/Sanjays81301051/status/1436229685180993559?s=20

5th Asian Yoga Therapy Conference Topic: Integral Yoga of Sri Aurobindo Date: 21st September 2021 Time: 10:00 am to 11:00am SGT Register for the conference below! https://asianyogatherapy.com/conference-5.php… #AYTA2021 #asianyogatherapy #yogatherapy https://twitter.com/Ajay_Anadi/status/1436229716575359022/video/1

The Manifestation of Light (LP04) - We take up today the first published poem of Sri Aurobindo, which was printed in 1883 when the author was 10 years old. This poem in retrospect appears a...

Kathāmṛta - 55 - Sūryaprabha-lambaka - The Story of Guṇaśarmā - One day, the king was having his meal. Guṇaśarmā, who sat in his proximity refused to eat a certain dish which was brought to him by the cook. When asked...

गज, ज्ञान और गणेश - गणेश उत्सव में गज, मूषक और दूर्वा हमें हर प्राणी और हर वस्तु का स्थान और महत्व समझने की प्रेरणा और ज्ञान देता है। The post गज, ज्ञान और गणेश appeared fir...

Billy Jack vs Dirty Harry - I am teaching a class this semester on the New Hollywood (i.e. American filmmaking in the 1970s). Since the class is being conducted entirely online, I am ...

Understanding and Overcoming Obstacles That Obstruct the Psychic Opening - If human nature can be changed, it has to be at the place where motives and impulsions affect the understanding and the action. The sadhana thus entails a ...

Dust to dust: A religion of return migration - Below I recount [a] story of death and repatriation in times of Covid-19, not in the voyeuristic manner of mainstream media coverage—producing a narrativiz...

Youth Center – Youth Network meeting - 6th of Sept 2021 Youth Center in collaboration with Youth Network organised a meeting to collect & harvest wishes, dreams, projects, ideas & aspirations 

Priya Satia's strange theory of History - Mircea Rainau has a good review article on Priya Satia's 'Time's Monsters' here. The main argument is most succinctly stated on pages 3-5, where Satia a...

Retraining Our Sensibilities - 2021 has been a quite disastrous and traumatic year for many, hasn’t it? If the events of 2021 haveb’t yet taught us that we need to retrain our sensibilit...

Another type of meditation — Mother - There is another kind of meditation which consists in being as quiet as one can be but without trying to stop all thoughts, for there are thoughts which ar...

Inseparability of aesthetics and spiritual experience - Integral psychology H Chaudhuri, K Wilber … Important writers in the field of Integral Psychology are Sri *Aurobindo*, Indra Sen, Haridas Chaudhuri, and Ken...

Bipin Chandra Pal articulated with greater eloquence the idea of Swaraj - Nation-in-translation: Interrogating the ethno-cultural discourse of “nation-ness” in the Bengali novel Anandamath S Chatterjee - Nationalism in India, 2021...

Highly influential teaching of Sri Aurobindo holds much promise of fruitful interaction between religions and cultures - Pt Satish K Sharma @thebritishhindu · 6h After being incarcerated by the Anglican Christianist occupiers of Bharat, and then being released, Sri Aurobindo s...

New Man shall transform our mortal tenement and bring our sobbing earth close to Paradise - Savitri Era @SavitriEra · 13h Plain & Simple: Anuradha Choudry, Aparna Roy, and Nilima Bhat https:// plasim.blogspot.com/2021/09/anurad ha-choudry-aparna-roy...

Anuradha Choudry, Aparna Roy, and Nilima Bhat - Nilima Bhat @NilimaTweets · 8h *The Conquest of self-will and the Enthronement of the Divine Will* I am honored to be speaking tomorrow, 8 September, my Gur...

Power of the words can bring castles down - Easy reference to the wide-ranging literature on Sri Aurobindo is a tough job. *Sri Aurobindo: A Descriptive Bibliography* by H. K. Kaul (1972) was a great...

Absolute happiness is attainable only through solitude - HTML] Spinning Solitude: Coronavirus and the Philosopher S Chakraborty - Sophia, 2021 … Autobiography of a Yogi was a great inspiration for many would-be yog...

Sri Aurobindo represented the crystallization of the rising soul of India - For everything there is a season. In the "politics of consciousness", you may have to back an otherwise brute or a philistine. Sri Aurobindo fought again...

Sri Aurobindo is neglected by the academic community - My college Senior the much maligned, hugely politically persecuted &now honourably exonerated the brilliant & mercurial Tarun Tejpal has written this tease...

The concept of the Ubermenschen was taken by Nietzsche from Renan - Adi Sankara and Aurobindo - Page 32 books.google.co.in › books Vedre Narayan Karan Reddy · 1992 · ‎Snippet view · ‎More editions The concept of the Ubermensc...

Psychology restores uniqueness as the outstanding attribute of the human being - Savitri Era: Modalities of social action need to be examined against present constraints https://savitriera.blogspot.com/2021/08/modalities-of-social-action...

His ideas were self-validating for Aurobindo - On The Life Divine The first parts of the book deals with the major problems and issues of modern, ancient and Indian philosophy and religion. After presen...

Sri Aurobindo's theory of the soul of the nation has remarkable Hegelian affiliations - Sri Aurobindo rose to the forefront of the national movement, causing a split in the Congress Party in the Surat session of 1907. He belonged with Bal Gang...

A guiding myth and an integral weltanschauung - Perhaps it is not correct to say that there is no coalescing myth or worldview that provides a focus for life today. But, if there is, it is a narrow one o...

Savitri Era Religious Fraternity: Inseparability of aesthetics and spiritual experience serfrat.blogspot.com/2021/09/insepa Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra Director, SELF-2005, Savitri Era Religion (2006), and Savitri Era Party (2007) Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.